Appeals court disqualifies Trump's N.J. prosecutor pick Alina Habba, rejecting DOJ challenge

Appeals court disqualifies Trump's N.J. prosecutor pick Alina Habba, rejecting DOJ challenge

Published Mon, Dec 1 2025

10:06 AM EST

Updated 55 Min Ago

Key Points

• Alina Habba, President Donald Trump's pick to serve as New Jersey's top federal prosecutor, remains disqualified, a U.S. appeals court ruled.
• The unanimous decision upheld a prior ruling from a lower federal court that Habba was unlawfully appointed.
• Habba was Trump's former personal lawyer and a key figure in multiple civil cases against the president, including those brought by New York Attorney General Letitia James and writer E. Jean Carroll.

Alina Habba, speaks after being sworn in as US Attorney General for New Jersey, in the Oval Office of the White House in Washington, DC, on March 28, 2025.

Saul Loeb | Afp | Getty Images

Alina Habba, President Donald Trump's pick to serve as New Jersey's top federal prosecutor, remains disqualified from serving in that role in either a permanent or acting capacity, a U.S. appeals court ruled Monday.

The ruling from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit is the latest judicial rebuke to the Trump administration's efforts to quickly install its preferred candidates in powerful law-enforcement jobs.

A three-judge panel, in a 32-page opinion, unanimously upheld an Aug. 21 ruling from a lower federal court that Habba was unlawfully serving as acting U.S. Attorney for the District of New Jersey.

"It is apparent that the current administration has been frustrated by some of the legal and political barriers to getting its appointees in place," Circuit Judge D. Michael Fisher wrote in the appellate ruling.

The unusual series of legal moves taken by the Department of Justice to install Habba, one of Trump's former personal lawyers, as an acting U.S. attorney demonstrates "the difficulties it has faced," Fisher wrote.

"Yet the citizens of New Jersey and the loyal employees in the U.S. Attorney's Office deserve some clarity and stability," the judge wrote.

Fisher and another judge on the panel, D. Brooks Smith, were nominated to the Third Circuit by Republican former President George W. Bush. The other judge, L. Felipe Restrepo, was nominated by Democratic ex-President Barack Obama.

Abbe Lowell and Gerald Krovatin, lawyers for one of the parties in the case challenging Habba's appointment, noted in a statement with Norm Eisen that Monday's ruling marks "the first time an appellate court has ruled that President Trump cannot usurp longstanding statutory and constitutional processes to insert whomever he wants in these positions."

"We will continue to challenge President Trump's unlawful appointments of purported U.S. Attorneys wherever appropriate," the lawyers said in a joint statement.

Read more CNBC politics coverage

• Judge dismisses James Comey and Letitia James cases over 'unlawful' prosecutor appointment
• Sen. Mark Kelly faces Pentagon probe for video on refusing 'unlawful orders'
• Trump spoke with Chinese President Xi
• Bessent says no recession in 2026 but notes some sectors are challenged
• U.S. lawmakers say Rubio told Trump's Ukraine peace plan is Russia's 'wish list'

In March, Attorney General Pam Bondi appointed Habba as Interim U.S. Attorney, following the quick resignation of her previous pick. Trump nominated her in June, but she never underwent the Senate confirmation process, a Constitutionally-mandated step that can be lengthy and contentious.

Habba could only legally serve as an interim prosecutor for a limited time under the Federal Vacancies Reform Act. As that deadline neared, the Trump administration took a number of steps to keep Habba in the role.

The DOJ fired Desiree Grace, who was set to become interim U.S. attorney for the district after Habba's scheduled departure. Trump then withdrew Habba's nomination, and Bondi appointed her as both "Special Attorney" to the attorney general and the First Assistant U.S. attorney, aiming to elevate her automatically to acting U.S. attorney.

But the appeals court panel ruled Monday that those actions failed to comply with the provisions of the FVRA.

"Therefore, we will affirm the District Court's disqualification order," Fisher concluded.

The ruling came one week after another Trump-picked prosecutor, Lindsey Halligan, was deemed invalidly appointed.

That ruling, which disqualified Halligan as interim U.S. Attorney for the Eastern District of Virginia, also threw out the cases she brought against two major Trump foes: former FBI Director James Comey and New York Attorney General Letitia James.

Monday's appellate ruling on Habba did not dismiss the underlying criminal charges against the two people who had challenged her appointment.

Source